AIDA afstemning: Ændring af dommer-udvikling

Fridykkerudvalget under DSF bruger dette forum til at kommunikere med alle fridykkerinteresserede i Danmark.
Du er velkommen til at stille spørgsmål her - vi vil svare tilbage så snart vi kan.

AIDA afstemning: Ændring af dommer-udvikling

Indlægaf Camilla Salling » 12 mar 2017, 14:32

I denne tråd kan der diskuteres det nye forslag om ændring i, hvordan dommere kan udvikle sig med erfaring mv.

Her er oplæg fra AIDA international...

Principles, follow:
1. To split judges by division pool and depth;
2. Levels E and AI stay same does not split;
3. Combination of experience and competitions in promotion;
4. Judges can not be returned to a lower level in process of changing new IOP;

Judge Level E:
• Successful completion AIDA judge course;
• 18+ years
• 1 Competition as competitor;
• Member of AIDA National

Judge Level D:
D Depth division:
• Minimum of 100 points total (depth, pool, CEC)
• Minimum of 50 depth points
• Minimum 2 depth competitions;
• Recommendation by Judge responsible and approval by the Board;
• Recommended, but not required: certifications BLS and CPR;
• Recommended, but not required: Basic Scuba or PADI Open water or
equivalent;

D Pool division:
• Minimum of 100 points total (pool, depth, CEC)
• Minimum of 50 pool points
• Minimum 2 pool competitions;
• Recommendation by Judge responsible and approval by the Board;
• Recommended, but not required: certifications BLS and CPR;
• Recommended, but not required: Basic Scuba or PADI Open water or
equivalent;


Judge Level C:
C Depth division:
• Minimum of 150 points total (depth, pool, CEC)
• Minimum of 100 depth points
• Minimum 4 depth competitions;
• Main judge or assistant judge at WC (depth) / WRA (depth) plus one more
judge or assistant judge on WC/WRA (can be pool)
• 1 CEC participation;
• Recommendation by Judge responsible and approval by the Board;
• Recommended, but not required: certifications BLS and CPR;
• Recommended, but not required: Basic Scuba or PADI Open water or
equivalent;

C Pool division:
Minimum of 150 points total ( pool , depth, CEC)
Minimum of 100 pool points
Minimum 4 pool competitions;
Main judge or assistant judge at WC (pool) / WRA (pool) plus one more judge or assistant judge on WC/WRA (can be depth)
1 CEC participation;
Recommendation by Judge responsible and approval by the Board; Recommended, but not required: certifications BLS and CPR;
Recommended, but not required: Basic Scuba or PADI Open water or equivalent;

Judge Level B:
B Depth division:
Minimum of 300 points total (depth, pool, CEC)
Minimum of 150 depth points
Minimum 6 depth competition;
2xMain judge or assistant judge at WC (depth) / WRA(depth) plus one more judge or assistant judge on WC/WRA (can be pool)
1 judge course intern
2 CEC participation ( 1 giving a course, teaching);
Recommendation by Judge responsible and approval by the Board; Recommended, but not required: certifications BLS and CPR; Recommended, but not required: Basic Scuba or PADI Open water or equivalent;

B Pool division:
Minimum of 300 points total (pool, depth, CEC)
Minimum of 150 pool points
Minimum 6 pool competition;
2xMain judge or assistant judge at WC (pool) / WRA(pool) plus one more judge or assistant judge on WC/WRA (can be depth)
1 judge course intern;
2 CEC participation (1 giving a course, teaching);
Recommendation by Judge responsible and approval by the Board; Recommended, but not required: certifications BLS and CPR; Recommended, but not required: Basic Scuba or PADI Open water or equivalent;


Judge Level AI:
• Minimum of 500 points total;
• Minimum of 250 depth points;
• Minimum of 250 pool points;
• Minimum 10 competitions;
• 3xMain judge or assistant judge at WC/ WRA plus 2x judge or assistant judge
on WC/WRA (opposite)
• 2 judge course intern
• 3 CEC participation ( 2x giving a course, teaching);
• Required: certifications BLS and CPR;
• Recommendation by Judge responsible and approval by the Board;
• Recommended, but not required: Nitrox, Oxygen providers, Basic Scuba, or
PADI Open water or equivalent;


I suggest to accept another rule. The Board has the right to propose a judge B level (depth or pool) for promotion to AI level when has additional experience as organizer major events or WC, safety with great experience, competitor with experience and excellent results, etc. Final decision of promotion on Board proposal will bring Assembly AIDA Int. in secret voting procedure.

Petar Bojovic
Camilla Emilie Salling Olsen
Københavns Fridykkerklub/Århus Fridykkerklub
Camilla Salling
 
Indlæg: 127
Tilmeldt: 19 jul 2011, 15:57
Geografisk sted: Odense

Re: AIDA afstemning: Ændring af dommer-udvikling

Indlægaf PeterJernlungerne » 12 mar 2017, 20:54

Jeg syntes at det giver fin mening at opdele pool og dybde. Især set i lyset at hvor få dybdekonkurrencer vi har haft danske dommere til at afholde over de sidste mange år.
Peter Dreier

Formand for
Herlev Dykkerklub Jernlungerne

(og ivrig fridykker)
PeterJernlungerne
 
Indlæg: 94
Tilmeldt: 31 okt 2011, 16:22

Re: AIDA afstemning: Ændring af dommer-udvikling

Indlægaf Evita » 15 mar 2017, 11:00

Jeg synes også, at opdelingen er fornuftig.
Eva Tommerup Johnsen, motionist og AIDA dommer, Roskilde
Evita
 
Indlæg: 89
Tilmeldt: 18 jan 2012, 19:53

Re: AIDA afstemning: Ændring af dommer-udvikling

Indlægaf Jesper Stechmann » 20 mar 2017, 10:08

JA - enig, godt med en opdeling.

Det er ikke alle dybdedommere der kan dømme en poolkonkurrence.
Poolkonkurrencer er klart de konkurrencer der stiller største ktav til dommerne.
Jesper Stechmann

Aida Dommer
Fridykker Instruktør Træner
http://www.innerdive.dk
http://www.innerdivemalta.com
Brugeravatar
Jesper Stechmann
 
Indlæg: 352
Tilmeldt: 19 jul 2011, 11:19
Geografisk sted: Malta

Re: AIDA afstemning: Ændring af dommer-udvikling

Indlægaf Nikolaj Larsen » 20 mar 2017, 17:37

Evita skrev:Jeg synes også, at opdelingen er fornuftig.


Den kan jeg kun tilslutte mig - Pool og dybde er 2 helt forskellige setups - at have stor erfaring i det ene, betyder ikke man er god til den anden del pr. automatik.
Nikolaj Larsen
Københavns Fridykkerklub
http://www.kfk07.dk
Aida Judge
Brugeravatar
Nikolaj Larsen
 
Indlæg: 1277
Tilmeldt: 19 jul 2011, 15:04
Geografisk sted: Kirke Såby

Re: AIDA afstemning: Ændring af dommer-udvikling

Indlægaf Evita » 27 mar 2017, 10:10

Assembliet vedtog forslaget.
Eva Tommerup Johnsen, motionist og AIDA dommer, Roskilde
Evita
 
Indlæg: 89
Tilmeldt: 18 jan 2012, 19:53


Tilbage til Fridykkerudvalget under DSF

Hvem er online

Brugere der læser dette forum: Ingen tilmeldte og 1 gæst